brevoortformspring:
This time last year I was reading about ten books a month. Three of them were DC titles. Two of the DC’s books I was reading and enjoying had their writers quit due to issues with editorial in the middle of long running story arcs. As a result I dropped those books and…
Brevoort not just reading this, but actually posting it to show he read it, gives me a lot more respect for him than I was feeling up to this point.
I’ll be honest, it’s hard for me to figure out precisely where things stand with Brevoort on this specific issue. I don’t think Brevoort made the call. I think if it really was all his call, and he really always wanted to do this from the get-go, then all the Avengers-driven material that had the Magnus family sans Lorna on prominent display would never have happened. Children’s Crusade wouldn’t have happened, and there would not have been big moments in Avengers vs X-Men.
I also think that if he didn’t care about the Magnus family at all, then he would not have ignored Lorna being part of it in everything he oversaw, and he wouldn’t have tried to make excuses for why she shouldn’t be part of the family. It would be easy for me to spin him as not appreciating the family due to not appreciating Lorna, but the truth is that I think he just doesn’t see how good it is for all three of Magneto’s kids to be his kids, and I think he thinks Lorna “tarnishes” the family when she actually helps make it all the more exciting.
What’s hard for me to suss out here is whether retconning Wanda and Pietro out of the family was orders from above or a conscious choice he made himself. I can see Brevoort not wanting to do the retcon, but not fighting it because he doesn’t have enough pull with anyone to risk it. However, I can also see him deciding on this retcon not because he was told to do it, but because something in the corporate culture he’s part of made him think the change would look good to people above him.
I’ve been oscillating between the two, and most of the time I assume the latter. I’d like to assume the former, because I feel bad about expecting the worst out of people, but it’s hard for me to assume the former after some of the things he’s said in the past.
Overall, I really do hope this retcon is undone quickly (within a month or two), and we have all three of Magneto’s kids confirmed as his kids and doing stuff together.
Last note of my own. Looking at it purely as a story turn and character development, I didn’t mind Alex’s anti-mutant speech. Alex has a history of not appreciating his own heritage (e.g. when he left the X-Men for a “normal, civilian life” in the late 60s/early 70s), and it’s really not that farfetched for someone of a minority to not recognize or value his own minority’s culture. This is why I didn’t really go into outrage mode or start dropping films, games or comics over it. It only started to look like an issue to me in conjunction with many other elements that, when taken together, look nothing like unfortunate accidents and more like a deliberate trend for the worse.
Modern Marvel and the longtime reader