I’ll say this about Cullen Bunn’s focus on Havok on X-Men Blue: it’s gotten me in enough arguments with Havok fanboys to make me hate Havok more than I did before his run.

All I’ve ever asked for in regards to their relationship was to keep them apart for long enough that Lorna got to properly establish herself as her own character without him. I judged that to require 10 years apart since 5 didn’t suffice in the 00s. That’s literally all I asked. I didn’t ask for Havok to be kept away from her forever. I didn’t ask for Havok to be treated like shit for Lorna’s benefit to “make up for” all the times she got treated like shit for his benefit. Before Blue, I didn’t even hold Havok being forced into Lorna’s origin story, or into her leading her own team on ANXF, against him.

But after X-Men Blue #8 and #9, after the heavy upcoming focus on him for the next Blue story arc, and after arguments I’ve been in (especially one where a Havok fanboy’s been outright lying by saying they’ve been apart for 10 years when it’s only been 6 at best), I increasingly find myself thinking “fuck Havok.”

Lorna can’t do a single fucking thing without Marvel shoving him into Lorna’s affairs, and she can’t have a leadership role, a starring TV role, a supporting role, anything without Havok fanboys trying to put Lorna or her options down and acting like she isn’t a viable character without him. Including trying to make her interactions with Magneto out to be worse for her than the literal decades of trash treatment she’s endured with Havok, because of course.

If the goal is to wear out my very hard effort to not hate Havok and if the goal’s to kill my ability to remain open to their having a relationship once Lorna’s in good shape, congratulations, it’s fucking working.

Luna, Wiccan, Speed: McDonalds! McDonalds! McDonalds!

Magneto: *pulls up to McDonalds*

Luna, Wiccan, Speed: *cheer*

Magneto: *orders a black coffee and leaves without paying*


Luna, Wiccan, Speed: McDonalds! McDonalds! McDonalds!

Quicksilver: *runs in without the kids, makes a black coffee for himself, pays and leaves*


Luna, Wiccan, Speed: McDonalds! McDonalds! McDonalds!

Scarlet Witch: I can make food at home out of thin air.


Luna, Wiccan, Speed: McDonalds! McDonalds! McDonalds!

Polaris: *rips roof off McDonalds, floats McDonalds food into the car*

Polaris: 

McDonalds! McDonalds! McDonalds!

Polaris: *floats money into registers, fixes roof and leaves*

Marvel’s Bias Against Polaris, For Havok, via Social Media

Quickly showing another tiny amount of further evidence of why Havok forced into Polaris’ affairs is a big issue for me. By comparison.

Here’s what the official Marvel account for Latin America on Twitter posted a couple days ago.

image

Now here’s everything the official Marvel account has tweeted about Lorna, with keyword Polaris.

image

Notice that the official Marvel account has never acknowledged Magneto is Lorna’s father.

Also notice that 4 out of 7 tweets invoke Havok in some way, to reassert the attitude that Lorna doesn’t matter or deserve to be talked about unless Havok gets something out of it. Notice that when they’re talked about, Havok’s name always comes first, as an implicit note that he’s perceived as “better” and “more important” than her.

I didn’t make a picture of it, but here’s what you get if you do the same search for Havok instead of Polaris.

https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&vertical=default&q=Havok%20from%3AMarvel&src=typd&lang=en

Havok gets 21 tweets. Polaris only comes up in 3 of them.

Let’s sum this up in statistics.

  • Number of tweets for Polaris: 7
  • Number of tweets for Havok: 21
  • Polaris tweets mentioning/showing Havok: 57%
  • Havok tweets mentioning/showing Polaris: 14%

The social media for @marvelentertainment reflects Marvel’s negative, biased attitude toward Polaris. To Marvel, Havok is a diverse character that can be all sorts of places and be many things, but over half of who Lorna is should be defined by being Havok’s girlfriend.

To Marvel, Havok deserves 3 times more promotion and support than Polaris.

This is all stuff you can see plainly if you pay attention to the comics, but you don’t even need to do that. Marvel makes it obvious with their social media activity.

Some people try to claim what Claremont did to Polaris during his run was somehow good. Here’s how they’re wrong.

If Claremont’s treatment of Polaris was so great:

  • Why did his use of her never lead to her getting a comic book solo?
  • Why didn’t she get her origin story told until 2013 (she was created in 1968)?
  • Why didn’t she get to lead a team of her own until 2014?
  • Why is she increasingly marginalized by Marvel, who either never use her in events, or generally only use her as a brief nameless cameo?
  • Why has she never had a single real, fully-used potential love interest besides Havok since the love triangle she had with Iceman and Havok in the late 60s/early 70s?
  • Why does she have no notable consistent friendships since Claremont kicked Lorna out of Jean Grey’s circle of friends?
  • Why didn’t she get a playable version in a video game until Lego Marvel Super Heroes in 2013, and only two brief background cameo appearances in games before it?
  • Why didn’t she get a live action version until Gifted in 2017?
  • Why didn’t she get to be a meaningful regular in a cartoon until Wolverine and the X-Men in 2008-2009?

Claremont is famous for having done a lot of good things for a lot of other characters. Claremont fanboys/fangirls, and people beholden to nostalgia, follow this to insist that Claremont was practically a writing god incarnate and could never have possibly done any wrong.

But that’s not true. His treatment of Polaris screwed her over. It stripped her of relationships and the potential for them. It reduced her to smaller and smaller roles that only existed to benefit other characters. It pushed back her character development by decades. It left Marvel and future creators with the impression that she wasn’t “good enough” to “deserve” so many things other characters created when she was or after her received much sooner and in spades.

To this day, how Claremont treated Polaris shapes impressions of her value at Marvel. There’s a specific editor there who years ago insisted she didn’t belong in the Magnus family and used his editorial power to exclude her from it, and the real reason comes down to his nostalgia for the Claremont era. He saw what Claremont wrote of her, saw how Claremont considered her worthless and undeserving of good things, and carried that into his own work at Marvel.

As I’ve said before, this year is Polaris’ 50th anniversary. Is Marvel going to do a single thing for her during it? I expect not. If anything, I personally expect they’ll throw her into limbo for the rest of the year once X-Men Blue is done. The reason comes back to Claremont. If not for him, Marvel might view this year as important enough to do some meaningful things for her, like they did for Squirrel Girl’s 25th anniversary last year.

As I said, Claremont did good things for other characters and theoretically for the X-Men franchise as a whole. But a person doing good things in some places doesn’t mean every single thing they’ve ever done in their lives is perfection. He was bad for Polaris.