I wrote a thing on Twitter about Lorna, Marvel, and treatment of her in relation to male characters. I’m bringing it over here because I feel I got to an important place with it.

When Marvel actually bothers to acknowledge Polaris exists and use her, the biggest obstacle to overcome is getting them to see Lorna as her own character. It’s a problem that’s more insidious than it first appears.

Marvel editors and writers are entrenched with an idea of Lorna as defined by men. Which is an annoying problem, because Lorna started out very feminist and empowering for her time, especially compared to Jean as SHE was written at the time.

image
image

Then, over the span of a few decades, Lorna’s treatment by Marvel declined from “not who takes who to the next sock hop” and “I’m nobody’s girl,” to fawning over how she gets to be Havok’s domesticated pseudo-housewife/girlfriend that needs him to rescue her.

image
image

Marvel writers and editors forget who Lorna is SUPPOSED to be. They only remember what later writers, especially Claremont, turned her into. So when they’re asked to do things with Lorna, they keep falling back on the bad later stuff instead of referring to the good early stuff.

Which is why they have problems with writing her male relationships. Gambit on All-New X-Factor and Magneto on X-Men Blue, both cases started out treating her relations with those men in the same way her relation with Havok has been historically treated.

And in both cases, ANXF and X-Men Blue, the writer DID eventually do better in her dynamic with Gambit and Magneto, respectively. But that they had such trouble at all underscores the problem Marvel writers and editors have of a tendency to devalue Lorna and overvalue men.

I’ve complained a lot (for damn good reason) about Lorna’s treatment on X-Men Blue in relation to Havok. But right now, I want to point out a couple good things Bunn did on Blue. They weren’t enough, but they were still small bright spots.

  1. Bunn improved his treatment of Lorna in relation to her father. There were major problems Pre-#15, and he fixed those issues by the end of his run.
  2. Bunn acknowledged Malice as part of Lorna’s history. Lacking in execution, but he brought it back without it hurting Lorna in the process.

There is a lot else I could say. But I am very deliberately forcing myself to keep this post short. I know if I let myself go longer, I’ll start complaining extensively, or explaining things, and I don’t want to do that this time. I just want to highlight the couple positives and stop there.

biwandamaximoff:

anyways im sick of the house of m girls’ narratives being always focused around men. wanda spent half of her solo focused on male relatives and 80% of writers don’t even acknowledge lorna as anything other than havok’s girlfriend. i’m fucking sick of it.

Complete agreement here on Lorna.

On Wanda, I didn’t read it so I can’t say much. Except that I felt Marvel’s forced retcon on her parentage meant it robbed her of potentially great stories with Lorna.